A place of prayer and practical support for good, faithful priests grappling with corruption in the hierarchy of the Roman Catholic Church. We believe in one HOLY catholic and apostolic church.
#Sackcloth and Ashes
Get link
Facebook
X
Pinterest
Email
Other Apps
I've noticed a lot of people are organizing prayer and action in response to this scandal. Here's one by the blog Catholic All Year.
I see a lot of people blaming homosexuality for the horrible mess the Church is in right now. I think though this thinking is really skewed, understandably so, because of the nature of the abuse and flouting of Church Teaching. And I am completely orthodox on the Church's teachings on sex. So I in no way condone homosexual behavior. However, something is amiss here. I was hearkening back to to my days of formal logic. You know those syllogisms that go All men are mortal Socrates is a man Therefore, Socrates is mortal I think the premise in a lot of people's arguments against men with same sex attraction goes like this: All priests should be celibate Homosexuals are incapable of being celibate Therefore no homosexuals should become priests. The flaw I see in this argument is that the Church asks those with same sex attraction to remain celibate whether they are priests or laity. If you are burdened with same sex attraction, you...
Father Boniface Ramsey who was the whistle blower that tried to alert the local Church authorities about McCarrick 20 years ago, is interviewed here. One quibble I have is his characterization of a priest 'falling' once in a while in terms of celibacy. I get that we are all sinners and such things can happen. However, there is also a spectrum between occasionally 'falling' and being a predator. It seems like an awful lot of priests like to hang out in gay bars and deliberately hide behind celibacy to cover for their activity. The atmosphere in seminaries and in the priesthood (there seems to be plenty of drinking and social time going on) seems to often be occasions or near occasions of sin I agree that the crisis isn't just about homosexuality. This actually really angers me when people say that it is. Obviously that is a complicating factor here. But what about the 20 percent of abuse victims who weren't boys/men? Let's ...
Comments
Post a Comment