Michael Brendan Dougherty Sums Up the Current Status

Here at the National Review

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Homosexuality and the sex scandals

(NB:  The article I'm linking to might make some people really angry.  As a Catholic I am called to love everyone, my neighbors and my enemies.  And to face this crisis down, we must be honest and open and examine everything.  So if you are angry, please don't comment in anger, just state your opinion in a dispassionate way. Not that anyone is commenting here anyway.  LOL.  It's probably a moot point.) Here's an article by a priest who is very un-pc and calls homosexuality the main cause of the scandals. Please read it in its entirety.  It is true homosexuality does seem to be a prominent feature of the scandals.  And it does seem logical to think that the reason why the bishops excluded themselves from the Dallas Charter might have been because the homosexual networks were so deeply ingrained it would render the Church's organization unsustainable to weed out every homosexual bishop or priest. I am trying to think through all this.  My n...
Read more

Syllogisms and Church Teaching

I see a lot of people blaming homosexuality for the horrible mess the Church is in right now.  I think though this thinking is really skewed, understandably so, because of the nature of the abuse and flouting of Church Teaching.    And I am completely orthodox on the Church's teachings on sex.  So I in no way condone homosexual behavior.  However, something is amiss here.  I was hearkening back to to my days of formal logic.  You know those syllogisms that go All men are mortal Socrates is a man Therefore, Socrates is mortal I think the premise in a lot of people's arguments against men with same sex attraction goes like this: All priests should be celibate Homosexuals are incapable of being celibate Therefore no homosexuals should become priests. The flaw I see in this argument is that the Church asks those with same sex attraction to remain celibate whether they are priests or laity.  If you are burdened with same sex attraction, you...
Read more